Archives

November 2026
M T W T F S S
 1
2345678
9101112131415
16171819202122
23242526272829
30  

How to ruin a great company without really trying

Readers may or may not be aware that there’s a rather unpleasant scrap going on in the business world between US computer and printer company HP (Hewlettt Packard) and a British company called Autonomy which HP bought for about $10bn in late 2011.

But in November 2012, about a year after paying $10bn for Autonomy, HP bosses announced a $8.8bn writedown because the British software company wasn’t worth quite as much as HP executives had previously imagined. So now HP are threatening to sue Autonomy’s former owners and accountants for billions:

hp

But this is not the first time HP has paid billlions to buy another company and then had to admit the whole thing had been a massive cock-up. In August 2012, HP announced it was writing off around $8bn because a company it bought for $13.9bn a few years earlier (EDS) wasn’t worth quite as much as HP management had previously thought or hoped.

To paraphrase Oscar Wilde’s Lady Bracknell in The Importance of Being Earnest: ‘to write off $8bn one time may be regarded as a misfortune; to write off $8bn twice looks like carelessness’.

Now, there’s nothing wrong with a company losing money. It can happen to the best of businesses – a competitor may cut prices, a new technology may make a company’s products outdated, a change in consumer taste might catch a company out. And if a company does lose money for one or more years, you hope the company’s executives will take action to restore profitability.

But writing off billions on companies you’ve bought is somehow much worse than losing money from normal competitive trading – either you paid billions too much or else your appalling management of the company you bought has unfortunately destroyed billions of your shareholders’ money. To do this once is certainly unfortunate, to do this twice does start to suggest words like ‘stupidity’, ‘incompetence’ and ‘bungling’ on an almost cosmic scale.

In fact, these weren’t the only writedowns HP’s management have recently made. There was also the not insignificant matter of HP writing off over $3bn in 2011 after it bought Palm computers a year before.

HP was an extraordinary success story. It was the first company in Silicon Valley and grew from two founders, Bill Hewlett and David Packard, working in a garage in 1939 to become one of the largest companies in the world with annual revenues of over $130bn and more than 300,000 employees in 170 countries. HP was so successful that one of its founders, David Packard, even wrote a book The HP Way explaining the unique business philosophy and management techniques the company used.

But the last few years have not been kind to HP. The share price was once above $130. But by 2013 it had collapsed at one point to around $13, making HP a member of what’s jokingly called “The Ninety Per Cent Club” – companies whose management have managed to reduce their value by ninety per cent.

The curse of the MBA?

HP’s impressive rise and even more impressive fall may not just be the story of only one company. Several once great American and British businesses seem to have followed the same sad trajectory as HP. They are started by innovators and entrepreneurs. By knowing their products and their markets they achieve rapid growth and are soon employing many thousands, sometimes hundreds of thousands, of people. Investors want a piece of their success and the share price heads towards the heavens.

But as the founders and those who have shared their vision retire, they are gradually replaced by a new generation of executives. This next generation probably all have top MBAs (Masters of Bugger All) from the best business schools and know all about the latest management theories and strategic models and quantitative techniques and marketing tricks and organization structures and so on and so forth. Moreover, the members of this new generation usually believe that their managerial skills can be used to run any business in any activity sector.

But all too often they are proved wrong. Knowledge of a company’s products and markets can be important and without it these MBAers find they don’t know how to continue the innovation that built the businesses they are now managing. In HP’s case, many of the lessons laid out in David Packard’s book seem to have been forgotten or ignored by the new generation of executives.

Unable to innovate their way to further growth and improved profitability, the MBA generation use the only two strategies they seem to know. Either they brutally cut costs to increase margins and their own bonuses. Often this demoralizes staff, reduces innovation and harms customer service. Moreover, it tends to lead to an exodus of the more talented employees as they leave to join the next wave of entrepreneurial, growing businesses. Or else, to make up for their own inability to grow the companies they run, the MBAers try to generate growth by buying younger, still entrepreneurial and growing companies, frequently at hugely inflated prices.  But then the MBAers impose the deadening grip of their own unimaginative management on their new acquisitions and stifle precisely the enthusiasm, creativity, innovation and entrepreneurialism they had paid so much to acquire.

Predictably the best people vote with their feet by leaving the newly bought company and the MBAers wake up one morning to find they are left with a very expensive, but almost worthless, empty shell and are forced to make massive writedowns on their acquisitions. Then they buy yet another growing company and the cycle repeats itself – costs are mercilessly cut in the acquired company, more talented employees leave and there’s another huge writedown.

Looking at HP’s three massive writedowns one could get the impression that a bunch of puffed-up but useless MBAers are managing to destroy a once great company without really trying.

Why does Sir Michael Parkinscum do it?

Hopefully you have a busy and fulfilling life and never waste any of it watching daytime TV. But if you ever did see any daytime TV, you’d find yourself bombarded by ads like this one where Sir Michael Parkinscum CBE tries to flog you probably one of the worst insurance products you could ever buy:

Parkinscum’s ad appears between endless repeats and alongside a torrent of ads from ambulance-chasing lawyers and rip-off short-term loan sharks.

Parkinscum is, I assume, a rather wealthy man and at 80 years old hardly needs any more money. So why is he debasing himself by getting lonely, bored pensioners to part with their often meagre savings for poor-value insurance deals?

The product Parkyscum is flogging is an AXA Sun Life over-50s assurance plan whereby you pay in a certain amount every month until you die and in return get a fixed payout on death which it is suggested will help cover your funeral costs or maybe leave a little cash for your heirs.

There are several problems with Parkyscum’s little scheme:

1. Missed payments –  If you miss just one month’s payment between the time you start the policy till your death, you get absolutely nothing, zilch, zero – Axa Sun Life keep all your money. So, if you were hospitalised before your death and missed your last payment or if you went into a care home because of dementia and nobody kept up your payments – that’s it, all your money gone. Moreover, I believe the statistics which Axa Sun Life would have show that more than half the people taking out such policies abandon them and so lose all their money. Being a bright man, Parkyscum would know this. A cynic might unkindly suggest that being a greedy man, he wouldn’t give a toss

2. Inflation – the payout sum is fixed and not linked to inflation. So, if you paid in for say 25 years and inflation was running at the BoE target of just 2%, the final sum you receive would lose over 60% of its purchasing power – basically, it would be next to worthless and certainly wouldn’t pay for much beyond a small, damp bonfire to dispose of your mortal remains – so, no regal funeral for you

3. Poor value – with people living longer, most of the more than a million people in the scheme will pay in considerably more than they will get out. The longer you live, the more you pay, but your final payout on death is fixed at the start. The only people who might gain would be those who are in poor health, heavy smokers or obscenely obese and could die within ten to fifteen years of starting the thing

In one case cited during a recent investigation, an 84-year-old woman had a guaranteed payout of £2,738, but had already put in £3,727. And while she lived, she paid — £22 a month for the rest of her life, to fund a nest egg that could not grow and, in fact would lose value each year because of inflation. So, if she lived for another 10 years, she would end up paying in £6,367 but only get £2,738 on her death. Not a great return.

The heavy use of Parkyscum’s ad suggests his celebrity endorsement is paying off: more than 790,000  people have apparently signed up since his ad started running. Hopefully they’ll all be enjoying the free Parker pen they get just for enquiring as most of them will end up paying an awful lot for that ‘free’ pen

As money expert Martin Lewis warned, “He’s a lovely man, that Parky – just don’t listen to him when it comes to insurance”.

But, of course, the video I want you and everyone you know to watch is this one:

Please support this website by forwarding this video link to your contacts.

Where will Red Ed find the money? In your pocket

We know that Red Ed and his boss Len McCluskey want to ‘bring back socialism’, and Harriet Harperson says ‘the middle should pay more’, so here are a few ways Red Ed could raise money for the massive splurge in public spending that he wants to unleash in order to subsidise the workshy and fund open borders immigration from the Third World:

– Increased income tax over £40,000, with new bands leading to 60% over £80,000 and 75% over £100,000 pa.

– Increased tax on investment income (dividends)

– A new wealth tax with the threshold starting at £1m.

– Increased capital gains tax, at personal income tax rate, with no provision for inflation and reduced tax-free band to £5,000

– Capital gains tax introduced on sale of principle residences. Threshold £500,000.

– Inheritance Tax rates starting at 50% (up from 40% today) with new bands up to 75%, and an end to loopholes such as the one he and his brother used to reduce tax on their father’s estate

– A council tax revaluation and removal of the council tax freeze leading to large council tax increases for all homes

– Additional 50% council tax for second residences.

– An immediate new Mansion Tax on all homes worth £2m or more as an interim measure before the new wealth tax in 2017, threshold £1m

– No state pension for those with private provision over £20,000 pa

– Exchange controls from 2016, annual limit £5,000, to prevent people moving their money out of the reach of his many new taxes

In addition, to ensure Labour stay in power, even after they have completely destroyed the economy, he will lower the voting age to 16 for the 2020 election.

And to ensure Britain never again has the temerity to imagine it is a proud independent country , he will sneak through a massive handover of our sovereignty to whoever rules Germany (and thus the EU)

That a third of the British electorate even consider voting for Ed Miliband is almost incredible. But then you have to remember that around 54% of British voters get more in benefits and public services than they pay in taxes. So they’ll always vote for whoever is willing to spend more of other people’s money on them. We really run the risk of getting the government the stupid, majority deserve. And that would be a disaster for Britain or the country formerly known as ‘Great Britain’.

ed miliband britain's future

(By the way, less than 300 people have viewed my new YouTube video. Yet the worst, most inane garbage gets 100,000s of views. Surely, some readers can be bothered to send the link to their contacts? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ds7XQJFBYTk We need many thousands of people to see this video, not just a couple of hundred)

Yippeee! I’m going to be rich!

Here are just a few brief extracts from about 20 emails I received during the last week. Looks like I’m soon going to be very very rich! Though, I have been surprised at how many relatives I apparently have who have recently died in plane crashes in Africa:

Hamed Soomani

Dear friend, Assalam alaikum,

I am the head of Accounts and Audit Department of Bank of Africa, Ouagadougou . I decided to contact you after a careful thought that you may be capable of handling this business transaction which I explained below;

In my department, I discovered an abandoned sum of $13.6m US dollars in an account that belongs to one of our foreign customer who died along with his entire family in 2003 in a plane crash…..

Dear friend,

I am Mrs. Joy Ulah, the head of file department of Bank of Africa (B.O.A) here in Burkina Faso / Ouagadougou. In my department I discover an abandoned sum of (US$18.2M) in an account that belongs to one of our foreign customer who died along with his family in plane crash.

It is therefore upon this discovery that I now decided to make this business proposal to you and release the money to you as the next of kin or relation to the deceased for the safety and subsequent disbursement since nobody is coming for it. I agree that 40% of this money will be for you while 60% would be for me. Then after the money is been transferred into your account, i will visit your country for an investment under your kind control.

You have to contact my Bank directly as the real next of kin of this deceased account with next of kin application form which I will send to you immediately I hear from you. I am waiting for your urgent respond to enable us proceed further for the transfer….

Dear Friend,

My name is Dr Ahmed Sani; I got your address in Burkina Faso chamber of commerce through yahoo details. I need your urgent assistance in transferring the sum of (22.5,000,000) Million Dollars fund which belongs to our deceased customer who died in A plane crash, Since the death of this our cuastomer the money has been in our bank without claim. I want to release the money to you as the deceased NEXT OF KIN for the benefit of both of us. By indicating your interest I will send you the full details on how the business will be executed. I need to hear from you urgent so that I will give you more information regarding this transaction.Waiting for your urgent response so that we will starts immediately.

Thanks,

Dr Ahmed Sani

email scams

Beloved

My sincere greeting to you, Please permit me to introduce myself, My name is Vivian Justin Yak, 24years old female (single) originated from Sudan. I appeal to you to exercise a little patience and read through my letter although, we have neither met in person but I decided to contact you personally for a long term business relationship and investment assistance in your country.

My father Dr. Justin Yak Arop was the former Minister for SPLA Affairs and Special Adviser to President Salva Kiir of South Sudan for Decentralization. My father Dr. Justin Yak and my mother including other top Military officers and top government officials had been on board when the plane crashed on Friday May 02, 2008………

Hello Dear,

“I would be very glad if you exercise a little patience and read my proposal for your understanding “I’m Ms Amina Kones, Nationality of Kenya, a girl of 25 years old, never married and a first year medical student. I am interested in you for a confidential discussion, may be like that, we can become best friends in the near future. I am writing with due respect, pains, tears and sorrow from my heart. I am bereaved from all side of my life. My Father (Kipkalya Kones) was the former Kenyan road Minister before his death and he died on plane crash since June 10, 2008, life has not been easy for me and i had been facing many challenges of life. $9,500,000……..

Joe Baba

I use this medium to contact you for negotiation of my proposition with you to secure and actualize this proposal for our mutual benefit and i wish to solicit your assistance in proposing an urgent transaction requiring maximum confidence.

You have to let me know your stand in this proposal so that i can send the details of the business to you and i will not fail to bring to your notice that this transaction is hitch free and that you should not entertain any atom of fear as all required arrangements have been made for the transfer.

I am awaiting for your immediate response as you receive this mail.

Yours faithfully,

Joel Baba.

Israel-hating Obama about to abandon USA’s only friend in the Middle East?

The West is moving towards negotiating a deal with Iran’s new leader, the one the Islamophiliacs at the BBC call a “moderate”. This deal will probably be heralded as a “great breakthrough” and as bringing a “new era of peace” to the troubled Middle East.  But in fact it will probably allow Iran to develop its first nuclear weapon. And when it does and attacks Israel, all those who allowed this will express shock and surprise. So it might be worth looking at what is really happening behind the scenes.

These are the key movers and shakers in Iran:

There was the former president Mahmoud “Mad” Ahmajinedad who has repeatedly pledged to wipe Israel off the face of the earth. But luckily Mad Mahmoud has been replaced by the nice new supposed “moderate” President Rouhani with his happy welcoming smile as he thinks back through all his fond memories of when, as Iran’s chief negotiator on its nuclear weapons programme, he lied to and fooled the West for years to buy Iran time to get its hands on the bomb. And there’s the Supreme Leader Ayatollah Khamenei who calls the shots and decides what really happens. Ayatollah Khamenei should not be confused with Ayatollah Khomenei (that’s his picture in the background) who did more than any other person to take Iran from the 20th century back to the Stone Age:

iran

Here’s what the boss, Ayatollah Khamenei, really thinks: “Israel is a cancerous tumor in the Middle East. Israel is a satanic media outlet with bombers. Every Muslim is required to arm themselves against Israel.”

“I have already noted the usurper state of Israel poses a grave threat to Islam and Muslim countries. Islam and Muslim states must not lose this opportunity to remove the corruption from our midst. All of our problems are because of Israel – Israel of America. The first step should be the absolute destruction of Israel.”

Like most Arabs, Khamenei blames Israel for everything that is wrong in the Arab world. Here’s a map of the Middle East:

Middle_East_Map_Labeled

Yup, you can hardly see Israel as it’s so small. The land area of Israel is just 21,000km2 compared  to 6,042,000km2 for the main Arab countries that surround Israel. So the Arab countries are 288 times larger than tiny Israel. The population of Israel is just 7.9 million (about the same as the population of Cairo) compared to 279 million for the major Arab states. Yet somehow, in the warped minds of Khamenei and most other Arab clerics and leaders, tiny Israel is responsible for all the problems in the Middle East. And the Islamophiliacs at the BBC swallow this ludicrous story.

I believe psychologists call this process of blaming others for our own self-induced problems “Attribution”. To continue to do this is a sign of a severe personality disorder and even mental instability. And we’re about to let psychotics have nuclear weapons?

psychopaths

What could possibly go wrong?

As for Obummer, does he expect gratitude from the Arabs? Does he think that once the Arabs have destroyed Israel, they’ll leave the West in peace. Perhaps one of Obummer’s advisers should remind him of the meaning of the Arab phrase “First comes Saturday, then comes Sunday”.

(and please could some readers send the link to our latest YouTube video – Africa by David Craig – to their contacts so that more people can see what really happens to our aid money our government so generously showers on Africa’s corrupt rulers https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ds7XQJFBYTk )

Please help send the message about our foreign aid to Africa being stolen

In a world of increasingly oppressive political correctness, there aren’t many voices daring to expose what is really happening in the world.

Hopefully, snouts-in-the-trough.com is one of the few voices that spits in the face of the politically correct.

That’s why I’m asking again for your support today. I’m not asking for money. I’m not even asking you to buy my books (I’ve given up with that as clearly my readers can’t afford books any more). All I’m asking is that you copy the link to yesterday’s blog featuring our new YouTube (3 minute video) and send it to as many people as possible asking them to send it on and so on.

Here’s the link: https://www.snouts-in-the-trough.com/archives/12726

Surely that’s not too much to ask.

If there are readers who don’t know how to send the link, then just email me at david.craig54@yahoo.co.uk and I’ll send you an email containing the link which you can then forward.

(As for missing comments. My site was attacked a few weeks ago with thousands of fake comments. There is a spam filter and things should be working again now)

Our YouTube film launched today – please send the link to all your contacts

Here’s the link to a short (3 minutes) YouTube video we’ve just released exposing how much of our foreign aid to Africa gets stolen by Africa’s rulers:

The video is based on one of the chapters in my latest book – THE GREAT CHARITY SCANDAL

My request to all readers is to send the link on to as many people as you can asking them to send it on further and so on.

If every reader sends the link to just 10 people and each of those sends it to 10 people and then each of those sends it to just 10 people, then hundreds of thousands more people would know about the scandalous theft of most of the aid we send to Africa.

This is the kind of politically-incorrect story no mainstream journalist would touch, even with a 500-foot barge-pole, for fear of being accused of “waaaccciiiissssmmm”

Thanking you in advance for helping to spread the word.

Ed Miliband’s 5-step plan to destroy Britain

Like his father, Ralph Miliband, Ed Miliband hates everything about Britain. He hates British history; he hates British traditions; he hates British culture; he hates the idea of Britain as a proud, independent country. For socialists like Ralph and Ed Miliband, countries are anachronisms. For socialists, country borders should be eroded and control handed over to an elite class of corrupt, self-serving, hereditary bureaucrats who know what’s best for the sheeple.

For socialists, democracy is a messy and largely unnecessary hurdle on the road to their centrally-managed socialist paradise. In the former USSR, these bureaucratic rulers were called ‘komissars’, in the new socialist heaven currently being created in Europe, the EUSSR, they’re called ‘commissioners’. So, not much difference there.

Ed Miliband will have achieved his father’s and his own life’s work if he can make the final push to emasculate Britain and push it under the full control of the mainly socialist commissioners in Brussels.

Sadly, Ed Miliband can do this in just five all too easy steps:

1. Crawl into Downing Street in May 2015 with the help of the SNP and maybe even the Greens.

2. Make huge concessions to the SNP, maybe even allowing them another independence referendum, even though the (IMHO) slimy, lying, bloated toad Salmond clearly stated there would not be another referendum ‘for a generation’

3. Continue Blair’s open door immigration policies allowing 46,000 people to pour into Britain every month for the next 5 years. As most of these people will  tend to vote Labour, that’s potentially another 2,500,000 Labour voters by the time of the 2020 election

4. Under the banner of ‘broadening democracy’ cynically extend the voting age down to include 16- and 17-year-olds, most of whom will vote Labour. That’s potentially another 1,500,000 Labour voters by the 2020 election

5. Irrevocably hand over power to the German-dominated racket that is the EU making EU law take precedence over British law and aurrendering what little control over our country we still have to whoever rules Germany

Miliband would never allow us a referendum on EU membership, because he already knows better than us what’s best for us. And that is being ruled by the undemocratic EU bureaucratic elites.

It is truly astonishing that a once great country like Britain could ever elect someone like Ed Miliband – a third-rate, pig-ignorant, self-serving, socialist utopian who has never had a proper job in his worthless life and who loathes the country he wants to run (into the ground).

Miliband must never get anywhere near Downing Street. But lying, u-turning, politically-correct, podgy dimwit dhimmi Dave Cameron may be unable to stop him.

At least former Labour leaders like Wilson and Callaghan, however misguided their policies, were patriots who wanted the best for Britain. But for traitor Ed, the sooner Britain disappears, subsumed into the EUSSR, the better.

Truly terrifying times ahead for Britain.

(Please remember, tomorrow Friday 27 March, snouts-in-the-trough.com launches its first YouTube video)

Sex paradise looking worryingly flaccid

My good lady wife and I have been spending part of the British winter in a beach resort just a vigorous stone’s throw away from one of the world’s most famous sin cities, which I’ll call HappyHappyTown. HappyHappyTown started it’s rise to ‘fame’ during the Vietnam War when US troops went there for R&R. When that ended, there were floods of sex tourists from Europe, USA and Australia and HappyHappyTown grew rapidly from a small fishing village into a major city with hundreds of establishments from gogo bars to bj-bars offering all kinds of services.

But recently, things haven’t been going so well in HappyHappyTown.

For any business to operate well you have to manage supply (having things to sell) and demand (finding customers who want to buy what you’re selling). And HappyHappyTown is having problems on both fronts:

Supply: For the last 40+ years, there has been a seemingly unlimited supply of RFFMs coming from the country’s impoverished rice-farming North. But now, as girls are getting better education, they no longer want to work in the ‘entertainment’ business. This has meant that the gogo bars and bj-bars have been struggling to recruit sufficient girls and are fighting over the few girls that are available. This has meant a sharp rise in salaries and the bankruptcy of several bars.

Demand: With most European countries in economic difficulties, there has been a sharp drop in Western sex tourists. Over the last few years, there has been a massive increase in Russian tourists to the Land of Smells. But with the ruble turning into rubble, these have dropped off too. Moreover, most of the Russians come as families, not for sex tourism. The area where there has been growth in sex tourism is from India and the Middle East. But they tend to get their girls either from night clubs or from the main prostitutes’ strip, not from gogo bars.

The other group of tourists that has seen a massive rise are the Chinese. But they come in huge groups, scuttle off their coaches like a crowd of cockroaches, waddle along following their tour leaders constantly filming with their cameras and selfie-sticks and then scuttle back into their coaches leaving behind a long trail of saliva and muccus (as they seem to spit and clear their noses everywhere they go). But they tend to never actually enter any gogo bars.

The result: The standard model here was a girl would work in a gogo bar earning about 15,000 baht a month (£300) for dancing 6 days a week from about 20.00h to 03.00h.

pattaya walking str

But she would increase her income by cadging drinks from customers (£1 per drink for her) and from ‘short time’ – having sex with a customer for about 2,000 baht (£40). In a reasonable month a girl could be taking at least 60,000 baht (£1,200). Due to the lower cost of living here, you have to multiply by at least five to get an idea of their real earnings. So, in a month a girl could be getting the equivalent of £6,000 taxfree. Five years of that and she has probably saved up enough to buy a small business – a shop or house with rooms for rent – and can retire.

But with the fall in gogo bar customers and the rise in the numbers of Indian and Middle East sex tourists, the girls in the gogo bars aren’t earning nearly as much as they used to. In fact, many gogos seem nearly empty a lot of the time. So the girls who still want to work in ‘adult entertainment’ are abandoning gogo bars and going freelance. After all, if they can earn 60,000 to 70,000 baht a month from just 2 to 3 customers a day, why bother exhausting themselves for 7 hours a day dancing on ridiculously high heels in a gogo bar?

At least 15 gogo bars have gone out of business in the last couple of years and more are expected to go to the wall in the next few years.

Behind the bright lights and loud music, things in one of the world’s greatest sex paradises are looking decidedly flaccid.

(Regarding the NHS – a reader asked yesterday if I had any figures comparing the number of managers in health services in other countries to the NHS. I have tried to find this several times, but without success. However, my first wife was a breast-cancer surgeon in a small European country. In her unit, which was quite a large department with five specialised surgeons, there were no managers. Instead it was up to the head of the department – a surgeon – working with the other surgeons to decide how much of their budget they wished to spend on administrative support. In fact, I think the surgeons would have been astonished if anyone actually suggested spending up to £100,000 a year of their budget on a manager for their department. The main hospital did, of course, have central management and administration. I imagine a specialised unit like that in Britain, would have at least 2 to 3 overpaid, over-pensioned and mostly unnecessary managers. But in that country the surgeons couldn’t see the need for any managers at all.)

(by the way, my latest book THE GREAT CHARITY SCANDAL is now available as a short paperback for just around 4 quid https://www.amazon.co.uk/The-Great-Charity-Scandal-Billions/dp/1872188117/ref=tmm_pap_title_0 )

 

Are we really managing our hospitals in the right way?

To stick with the NHS for just one more day. It’s over 20 years since I had the pleasure of investigating how one of our major hospitals was managed (or rather mismanaged). So, perhaps things have changed since then and the NHS is now super-efficient and positively humming with the latest management best practices.

But 20 years ago, we found that hospital management didn’t have a clue. Let me try to explain:

A hospital should be seen as a patient processing machine. The object – to get patients in, treat them safely but efficiently and then discharge them (that’s the top line on my simplified diagram). All services run by the hospital – pathology, radiology and others should be seen as supporting that goal:

hospital management

So, for example, if a patient is about to move onto some treatment but first needs pathology results to move to the next stage, then that patient’s pathology tests should be prioritised above those of a patient who perhaps won’t start full treatment for another couple of days. All this in order to smoothe the flow of patients through the system. Similarly, if a doctor was doing a morning round, he or she could be pretty certain that the’d be called away. So they should always start with those patients who can possibly be discharged that day.

But we found no understanding of this at all. Each department seemed to organise itself to make its own life easier without any understanding of the consequences on managing patient throughput. So, patients had treatments delayed while waiting for pathology results or patients couldn’t be discharged because the doctors didn’t sign them out by 10.30 or 11.00am or whatever the time was.

Moreover, there was absolutely no measurement of the utilisation of expensive equipment like million-pound scanners or limited, bottleneck resources like operating theatre time. The result – huge waste of money on underutilised resources and unnecessary delays in treatment.

I’ve no idea whether NHS hospitals still suffer from this problem – a complete misunderstanding of how to manage resources to ensure the best patient throughput results – or whether the NHS is now a shining beacon of highly focused, world-class, best-practice management.

But the fact that since New Labour came to power in 1997, the number of hospital beds fell from around 200,000 to about 135,000

hospital beds

while the number of managers shot up from about 25,000 (8 hospital beds per manager) to over 40,000 (about 3.5 beds per manager):

Hospital beds per manager

suggests that the NHS has learnt little to nothing and sees the solution to every problem as more managers rather than better management.

(You will see that the number of ‘beds/manager’ seems to have started to increase under the Coalition. The Coalition claims its NHS reforms have reduced the number of managers from a high of about 43,000 to about 38,000 now. This may be true. Or else, the NHS may be playing the classic civil service game – when told to reduce headcount, they hand out millions in redundancy or early retirement and then a few days later those people return as ‘independent self-employed’ consultants. So, we’re still paying for them, but they don’t appear on the employee headcount numbers. This allows politicians to claim huge success, while wasting even more of our money)

As for being ‘cash-strapped’ and ‘underfunded’ and ‘on the brink of collapse’. For a start, the average managerial salary in the NHS has more than doubled in real terms over the last 15 years. Moreover, any organisation that adds an extra 15,000 or so managers each costing say over £100,000 a year (salaries, NI, pensions, offices and administrative support) – total cost above £1.5bn a year – possibly has a little excess weight that could be comfortably discarded if it went on a diet.

And as few of our politicians have ever managed anything in their lives, they haven’t a clue how to improve NHS efficiency. So, they resort to the standard practice of fools – call in management consultants and reorganise, once again proving the old adage generally misattributed to Gaius Petronius: “We trained hard . . . but it seemed that every time we were beginning to form up into teams we would be reorganized. I was to learn later in life that we tend to meet any new situation by reorganizing; and a wonderful method it can be for creating the illusion of progress while producing confusion, inefficiency, and demoralization”